Scotts vs. Pennington: Product-by-Product Comparison

Last Updated on July 21, 2021 by Grow with Bovees

Growing a weed free lawn like this takes some effort.

When you get started with lawn care, it can be tough to understand exactly what you need to do to keep your yard healthy.

What you’ll quickly notice is that two companies are always present, whether you’re looking at grass seed or fertilizers. But when it comes to Pennington vs. Scotts, which one is best?

We’ll walk you through everything you need to know about these two companies and their products so you’ll know exactly what to pick.

These are some of the things we’ll go through in this article:

  • Understanding what lawn care products do.
  • Scotts vs Pennington: Grass seed comparison.
  • Why would you want to buy Scotts grass seed instead of Pennington?
  • What does Pennington do best?
  • Pennington vs Scotts fertilizer product comparison.
  • Should you buy Scotts or Pennington lawn fertilizer?
Get growing with ezseed or smart seed

Understanding What Lawn Care Products Do

The right lawn care products keep your grass green, your soil healthy, and help with weed control. To make your yard look perfect and feed the soil, you’ll need to invest in some grass seed and establish a fertilizer schedule.

Applying new seed every three to four years or when it starts thinning out keeps it free of weed plants or bare spots. If you have dogs tearing up the grass, you may have to do it more often.

Fertilizing a couple of times every year feeds your soil, giving it back some of the nutrients the grass absorbs from it. The correct fertilizer schedule ensures you make the most out of your grass seed investment and keeps the turf looking healthy with less water.

Now, let’s look into how Pennington and Scotts compare in seed and fertilizers.

Scotts vs Pennington: Grass Seed Comparison

To make your pick between the right grass seed for you, we looked into the best seed options from both companies. They both have well-performing seed blend products, so the right one depends on your level and needs.

Scotts Grass Seed

When it comes to grass seed, Scotts has product lines with seed mixes for many different types of grass. They all also cater to different conditions, from patch repair to sun and shade mixes.

Most of these seed options are coated with fertilizer, mulch and other enhancers, but the Heritage line contains the uncoated seeds.

The Turf Builder Tall Fescue is a widely popular mix among home gardeners that thrives in sunny areas and a warm climate. The EZ Seed is coated in growth enhancers and fertilizers that make it work well even if you’re not experienced.

Why Would You Want to Buy Scotts Grass Seed Instead of Pennington?

Scotts has a good variety of grass seed options, and they come with a germination guarantee. Scott products, especially EZ Seed, are ideal for new gardeners who aren’t yet pros with their lawn maintenance because the grass germinates and grows quickly.

This is especially true of the products that include Scotts high-quality mulch because it helps the seed hold water better. Scotts EZ Seed includes resistant varieties like bluegrass and ryegrass that grow anywhere, or they guarantee to give you your money back.

The Turf Builder Tall Fescue is another one we highly recommend for home gardeners.

Pennington Grass Seed

Pennington has a wider variety of grass seed options for different purposes and environments than Scotts.

The company’s basic seed product lines include Smart Seed and Lawn Booster. According to Pennington, Smart Seed uses 30 percent less water, which makes it an ideal option in areas that experience drought.

Smart Seed comes for cool and warm-season grass types, including tall fescue, fine fescue and red fescue grass, ryegrass and Kentucky Bluegrass. The common tall fescue is especially economical and popular among gardeners.

But along with the company’s regular products for common lawns with a sun and shade mix, Pennington makes mixes for special circumstances such as dense shade or high-traffic areas. The company also has a great product line called One Step, made specifically for quick patch repair.

What Does Pennington Do Best?

Pennington is a great option in grass seed, because it generally offers more seed per pound in grass seed mixes.

Pennington also offers a better variety of seed for different purposes and climates. If you want a special type of seed for a specific patch of your yard or if your grass suffers from being close to traffic, Pennington grass seeds are the right pick.

Should You Buy Pennington or Scotts Grass Seed?

Whether you should buy Pennington or Scotts grass seeds depends on your needs and how well-versed you are in gardening.

Scott seed is pretty much foolproof for beginners. Most of the company’s seed lines are coated in fertilizer and include mulch, which helps the seed grow anywhere. However, grass seed is expensive, and with Scotts you’ll be paying for less seed per pound.

If your turf grows in tough circumstances or you need patch repair or you are overseeding your lawn, Pennington is the right pick for seed.

Scotts vs Penningtons Grass Seed Comparison In A Nutshell

Still not sure about the right seed? Here’s a short comparison of the two seed options.

  • Pennington has a higher seed count per pound.
  • Scotts seed has the best germination rate and comes with a guarantee.
  • Pennington Smart Seed is better in drought conditions where water is scarce.
  • Scotts seed is user-friendly for beginners and normal sun-shade areas.
  • Pennington seed has a wider variety of grass seed mixes.

Pennington vs Scotts Fertilizer Product Comparison

Fertilizers are another necessary lawn care product. They feed your lawn the right macro and micronutrients to keep the soil healthy and the grass looking lush.

Here are the top fertilizers from both companies so you can make your pick.

Scotts Fertilizers

Scotts has two great products to fertilize your lawn year-round and keep it healthy, the Turf Builder and the 4-step program.

Scotts Turf Builder

Turf Builder is a general fertilizer that comes in many season-specific varieties. The all-season product has a 32-0-4 NPK content, which means it includes 32 percent nitrogen, less than 1 percent phosphorus and 4 percent potassium. This combination helps your lawn grow fast and strengthens the cell walls.

What’s great about the Scotts Turf Builder is that you don’t need to be an expert on lawn maintenance and understand the specific proportions you need of each nutrient. These products are very user-friendly, especially if you pick your fertilizer for each season and growth phase.

4-Step Program from Scotts

The 4-step program is another favorite of customers because it takes out all the thinking from your fertilizer use.

Just start with step 1 in the spring for weed control and growth, and move on to the next steps when needed. Steps 3 and 4 are specifically designed for early and late fall, when your lawn needs a little more strength to grow healthy.

Pennington Fertilizers

Pennington offers a wide variety of fertilizers for home gardeners and professional use.

Ironite for Extra Green

Ironite is technically not a fertilizer, but an iron supplement. It’s designed for use with your fertilizer of choice, to give your lawn a quick nutrient boost and make it thick and dark green.

Ironite gives you quick results, but it’s not enough to keep your soil healthy on its own. We recommend mixing it with fertilizer or any time your lawn needs a boost in iron.

Penningtons Ultragreen

The Ultragreen line is Pennington’s equivalent of the Scotts Turf Builder. It’s an easy-to-use beginner line with lots of options for all grass and soil types and climates. As with Turf Builder, this product is high in nitrogen, with an NPK ratio of 30-0-4. It also has 5 percent of iron to make your lawn extra green.

Pennington Lilly Miller Fertilizers

The Lilly Miller line from Penningtons has a variety of alternatives for fertilizing your garden beyond just your lawn. This line includes fertilizers for flowers and common garden crops, as well as pesticides to keep insects at bay.

Lilly Miller products are a good addition to your garden care products if you want to feed your roses and make the most out of your vegetable crops and fruit trees.

If growing fine roses is your thing, this can help.

Should You Buy Scotts or Pennington Lawn Fertilizer?

We recommend Scotts lawn fertilizers for their simplicity. While both companies have quality fertilizers, Scotts is easier to figure out for new gardeners. Penningtons has a more specialized range, which often makes it harder to know just what to use.

If you want a quick boost in color, do consider adding some Pennington Ironite to your fertilizing schedule. And for those who grow flowers, fruit trees, and vegetables in their yards, the Lilly Miller product line is worth investigating.

Comparing Pennington to Scotts in Summary

We love Pennington Smart Seed for most gardeners because of its higher amount of precious seeds per pound and because it uses less water. Scotts fertilizers and grass seed mix with mulch are our top picks for beginners because they’re so easy to use.

Both Companies Make Good Products

In the matter of Pennington vs Scotts, the truth is that both companies offer useful products for home gardeners. You can mix and match depending on your needs, going for a Pennington Smart Seed and Scott fertilizer for your lawn.

Later, you can complement your lawn care with a bit of extra iron or use Lilly Miller products for the rest of your garden.