Best Organic Lawn Fertilizer — Natural Ingredients for Great Results

Last Updated on August 23, 2021 by Grow with Bovees

use super natural lawn fertilizer for results like this

There’s nothing worse than a brown lawn in a sea of green. Fortunately, a little more brown—fertilizer this time—and your lawn may become the greenest of all.

Consider using organic lawn fertilizers for your lawn growth. With all-natural, chemical-free ingredients and a little patience on your part, you can go from the neighborhood dud to the neighborhood show-house.

Since there are so many organic yard fertilizer products out there, we’ve narrowed the selection down. The best organic fertilizer for your lawn is among the following contenders:

Preview
Best Manure Type
Espoma EOFW30 Organic Fall Fertilizer, 30-Pound
Best Bulk Buy
Milorganite 0636 Organic Nitrogen Fertilizer, Safer and Slow Release, for Lawn and Grass, Granular Nitrogen Fertilizer 32 lbs (Bundled with Pearsons Protective Gloves)
Best All Season
Greenworks 40V (185 MPH) Brushless Cordless Blower / Vacuum, 4.0Ah Battery and Charger Included 24322
Title
Epsoma EOFW30
Milorganite 0636
Scotts Natural
Best Manure Type
Preview
Espoma EOFW30 Organic Fall Fertilizer, 30-Pound
Title
Epsoma EOFW30
Best Bulk Buy
Preview
Milorganite 0636 Organic Nitrogen Fertilizer, Safer and Slow Release, for Lawn and Grass, Granular Nitrogen Fertilizer 32 lbs (Bundled with Pearsons Protective Gloves)
Title
Milorganite 0636
Best All Season
Preview
Greenworks 40V (185 MPH) Brushless Cordless Blower / Vacuum, 4.0Ah Battery and Charger Included 24322
Title
Scotts Natural
make your lawn safe to use with natural ingredients that matter to the soil

Preparing Your Lawn for Organic Grass Fertilizer

As nice as it would be to switch seamlessly to organic lawn fertilizers, it’s impossible. There’s some prep-work involved if you’ve been using synthetic fertilizers.

Before you’re ready to go organic with your lawn, ask yourself if you’re willing to do the work.

Test Your Soil

Every lawn is different and craves an array of nutrients it lacks. So, test your soil pH (see our soil tester review), to see what your lawn needs.

Your lawn requires more nutrients than you may realize. For example, mineral langbeinite will give it the magnesium it needs, where gypsum restores the lawn’s appropriate amount of calcium.

To figure out what you need to buy, fill two cups with soil, taking the samples from various spots around the lawn.

Next, find a soil testing service near you. Some universities offer this or visit your local garden center to see if they can do it.

Compost

To help your soil free itself from its reliance on synthetics, you must start applying compost to your lawn. Composting improves your soil’s structure, which can be damaged by incorrect or a lack of care.

You’ll need organic compost for your lawn, of course—made of dead plant and other organic matter.  If you want to save money, you should collect your own garden’s waste and plant debris from home, such as potato skins and other peelings, and start your own compost pile. Most yards will have a suitable site for a compost bin, even if it’s just a small one.

Spread your compost with a compost fork, all over the lawn, about half an inch thick. Also consider spraying your lawn with compost tea monthly. Continue this after your switch to the best organic lawn care products. Fertilizer can do the work on its own, but, should it? You’ll benefit more from multiple lawn care methods.

To have thick green grass, use a plant based compost to deliver nutrients your lawn.

Preparing Your Lawn for Amending It With Organic Yard Fertilizer

Once you break the synthetic-addiction your lawn has, you can start the prep work for the actual organic-fertilizing process.

Clean Up For A Healthy Lawn

Is there compost leftover on your lawn that didn’t break down? Stray leaves and twigs from nearby trees?

Get yourself a backpack leaf blower and remove that debris off your lawn to make space for the organic fertilizer.

You could use a rake, but do you want to risk disturbing your soon-to-be-fertilized soil? Plus, the blower will speed the lawn cleaning process up.

Mow It Short

Fertilizer won’t save an overgrown lawn that is already sprouting unwanted weeds. Mow your lawn short—leave maybe an inch of grass sprouting—and properly dispose of the lawn cuttings.

Kill Undesirables

Apply a gentle weed killer and pre-emergent to rid yourself of garden growth pests and potential crabgrass.

Try to go organic here—you don’t want to ruin your hard work. If you can get an organic pre-emergent/weed killer combo, it’s far more efficient and easier on the wallet.

Never neglect this step, especially the pre-emergent. You can kill and pull weeds any time, but if crabgrass sprouts on your lawn, it’s a battle you’ll have for the entire sunny season.

Reseed

Once you’ve applied the weed killer and re-emergent treatment successfully, reseed your lawn. Consider using organic grass seed for this.

This step is best done in fall, so your new grass will germinate and sprout in time for summer.

Reseed shortly before you use organic fertilizer, but don’t drown the new seeds in the fertilizer immediately. Wait for the new lawn to sprout a little.

It also helps if you overseed. This way, the seeds are more likely to fill out brown patches in the lawn if some fail to germinate.

Await Greener Grass

You’ve done as much as you can do—how do you know your grass is ready for purely organic fertilizer?

The lawn should start to grow in greener if you’ve followed all the steps laid out so far. It won’t be perfect; it’s still unfed after all, but when you see greener patches appearing, you know the lawn is well-prepped for organic lawn fertilizer.

Organic Lawn Fertilizer Reviews: The Top Contenders

There’s no need to fret about where to buy the best organic lawn fertilizer. We have some of the best options for you right here, which we selected after some in-depth research on organic lawn care.

make sure to choose products safe for kids and pets
Make sure your choice is safe for children and pets

1. Espoma EOFW30 Organic Fall Fertilizer

Do you want a lush, green lawn even in winter? Here’s a fertilizer you apply in the fall, and it keeps your lawn emerald until spring.

A bag of Espoma organic lawn fertilizer feeds 5,000 square feet of lawn with its sulfate of potash and feather meal-poultry manure combination.

It’s a granulated manure—the best organic lawn fertilizer type—you can easily use with a spreader if you have a lot of lawn to cover. Although “easily” refers only to your efficiency in spreading it—it’ll be a tough job if you’re sensitive to foul odors.

Luckily, consumers found that the smell dissipated upon watering, which didn’t occur with other natural fertilizers for organic lawn care that they’d used.

Besides the stench, the best kind of organic lawn fertilizer is harmless, and Espoma is no different—it’s safe for use if you have pets.

Barring the smell, customers say the only downside of this organic lawn care is the hefty price for the 30-pound bag, but many are in agreement that  it’s worth it for the best organic lawn care.

Pros

  • Keeps lawns alive in winter.
  • Safe for pets and the environment.
  • Terrible odor goes away when watered.
  • Highly effective fertilizer.
  • Large bag works for enormous lawns.

Cons

  • Foul odor.
  • Quite pricey.

2. Milorganite 0636 Organic Nitrogen Fertilizer

If you’re looking for a similar-sized bag to the previous product, but at a lower price, Milogranite is an excellent choice.  Even better, you can buy it in bulk, and it’s fantastic for lawns lacking in nitrogen.

Milogranite is the best organic lawn fertilizer for use on golf courses, according to the manufacturer, which isn’t surprising, thanks to its 32-pound size—it goes a long way.

Another reason this is one of the best organic lawn fertilizers for golf courses is that it also treats the grass, so it grows slower, reducing the amount of mowing and watering it needs.

This also makes it an excellent choice for people with a large garden or green area around their house.

Customers had fantastic results with this organic lawn care substance. The images they post online reveal it turns their lawns from patchy and varying in color to a deep, rich, uniform green.

As well as turning the average lawn into a golf-course like dream, customers say it also repels deer.

A small proportion of users say that you need a lot of the product to produce a measurable difference, some state you’ll need double the amount of other similar products. If this is so, it is no more cost-effective than the top product.

They also say it stinks with the odor hanging around for up to two weeks after application.

Pros

  • You can buy in bulk for a reduced price.
  • Turns patchy lawns into uniform, lush greens.
  • Compatible with all spreaders.
  • High nitrogen lawn fertilizer.
  • Reduces mowing and watering time.
  • Slowly releases nutrients, so you have to fertilize less often.

Cons

  • Lingering stench.
  • It takes a sizable amount to start working.

3. Scotts Natural Lawn Food

Not everyone wants to follow the seasons, and sometimes you only have time for lawn care in winter. Luckily this lawn food is effective year-round and harmless to the entire family—kids and pets included.

It’s not just safe in case of accidental consumption, though—it’s safe for them to run on immediately after application. This won’t affect the results, which should start to show after 1–3 weeks.

The timing of results is weather-dependent after the initial application.

Application-wise, the manufacturer recommends you use a rotary broadcast spreader and apply the fertilizer once per season.

You can also use the fertilizer before or after sewing your seeds, making it highly versatile and well-suited to anyone’s needs and time limitations.

Customers find it works well either way. It won’t fill in patches if you don’t seed your lawn, but it turns the grass you do have to a dark green and thickens it up.

Although, despite it not being synthetic, customers found that it yellows the grass if you use too much. If you spread it thinly, which is all that’s required, the bag is fit for 4,000 square feet.

Pros

  • Can be used in any season.
  • You can walk on the lawn immediately afterward.
  • Use before or after seeding.
  • Safe in case of accidental consumption.
  • The smell is subtle and fades fast.

Cons

  • Turns lawn yellow if piled on thickly.
  • Won’t rejuvenate patches of dead grass.

4. Safer Brand 9334 Lawn Restore Fertilizer

For a fast-acting fertilizer, here’s one to look into. Safer Brand’s fertilizer gets your lawn green in only 3–5 days.

Not only that, but a little of this goes a long way. One 25-pound bag covers up to 6,250 square feet.

The fast results come from how this fertilizer directly targets the grass’s roots. It strives to make the root system more robust, thickening your lawn and rejuvenating it in the process.

It also strives to keep your lawn in prime condition all year as it wants to help the grass withstand temperature fluctuations and even drought.

Although, customers say a previous version of the same product was better. This one, apparently, smells worse and is messy to spread.

However, the quick results and the pet-and-kid-safe formula may outweigh this. Not only can the fertilizer thicken existing grass, but it also helps fill in patches and reduce how often you need to water the lawn.

Customers say there are better brands out there, which is true; after all, this is #4 on our list. But for a thin spreading substance that works swiftly, it’s an excellent product.

Pros

  • Fast-working.
  • Strengthens roots.
  • Reduces watering time.
  • Works all year.
  • Safe for kids and pets.
  • Rejuvenates dead patches.
  • A little goes a long way.

Cons

  • Foul stench.
  • Messy to apply; small particles that fly in the breeze.
  • Not as impressive as other brands.
use organic matter for simple lawn care that is safe for children and pets

5. Jonathan Green 12192 Coverage Love Your Soil

Last but not least, we have a budget pick. For half the price of the selection above, you can get 1,000 square feet of grass growing healthy again. This isn’t a pick for someone with lots of land, but a small front lawn will benefit greatly.

You can also buy in bulk for more extensive areas at a very reasonable price—15,000 square foot coverage, for not much more cost than our top pick.

Quantities and pricing aside, this is an excellent and natural organic fertilizer for lawn growth. It feeds the soil and the roots, with users claiming it’s most effective in spring due to the soil’s warmth.

They state that warmth aids the soil’s microbes, which, in turn, release nutrients, although we haven’t found any studies backing the claim.

Once on, it keeps the grass healthy year-round and makes your soil much easier to deal with. It loosens the hard, compacted stuff to let the grass grow at a consistent rate. Even Florida-based customers with lawns on sandy soil found it a tremendous help.

As well as aiding the soil, this Jonathan Green organic lawn fertilizer turns your yellow lawn spots lush and makes the grass greener.

The chief complaints customers have aren’t about performance, but the size of the smallest bag. They compare it to a bag of coffee grounds and say you’re better off buying a larger bag—which eliminates the budget-pick part.

Some also say the company sells bags below the advertised weight across all sizes.

Pros

  • Affordable, if you feel the bag is big enough.
  • Helps keep soil moist and loose in winter.
  • Darkens and thickens grass nicely.
  • Creates a consistent growth rate.

Cons

  • Some bags are underweight.
  • Budget pick is allegedly tiny.
natural fertilizer in early spring for a healthy lawn

Green Color, Green Practice: The Benefits of Organic Lawn Fertilizer

With the products above in mind, you may wonder why you should bother with organic lawn fertilizer. It’s all so pricey!

The best organic fertilizers are worth the price, though, if you care about the environment. The benefits of going organic go well beyond lush lawns and glamorous green grass.

Chemicals are toxic. There’s a reason you can’t consume them without serious consequences to your health. They may have their benefits for some living things, but they’re detrimental to others.

Using chemicals has a severe negative impact on the environment. Despite getting your grass looking its best, these chemical-ridden fertilizers also:

  • Release greenhouse gases into the atmosphere.
  • Get washed into rivers causing algal blooms, which kills fish.
  • Increase soil nitrate levels too much.

So, chemicals may green your grass, but they make the planet less green in the process—their beauty is only surface-deep.

Since organic fertilizers are all-natural, they break down with ease while releasing excess nitrogen, but not at an air-polluting rate.

They also don’t chemically pollute water but settle harmlessly to the riverbed, with the rest of the dirt. If marine life consumes it, at most, they get a foul taste in their mouths.

Best Practices for Green Lawns With the Best Fertilizer

Now you’ve made the green choice, let’s put it into action. Here are the best fertilization practices for a green lawn:

Stay Loyal to Organic: Organic vs. Chemical

Outside the negative impacts of chemical fertilizers, they’re just not as good for your lawn as the organic stuff.

Organic Creates Stamina

Is it odd to talk about grass that has stamina? Maybe, but it’s true. Organic fertilizers give your grass and soil the ability to retain not just water, but nutrients too. With moist and well-fed roots, your grass and other plants can strengthen over time.

You Can’t Over Fertilize Easily

While chemical fertilizers are there to get the job done and get it done quickly, most organic fertilizers release their nutrients slowly as they break down.

With this slow-release nature of organic, it becomes increasingly difficult to over-fertilize the lawn.  

There’s No Toxic Buildup

The chemicals in chemical fertilizer contribute to your plants’ health in the short run, but what about the long term?

Many chemicals—like chloride—used in a variety of products are poisonous to living things, and some contain salt.

Salt damages plants, making it deadly if enough of it builds up in your lawn.

Organic is Environmentally Friendly

Since it’s all-natural in both creation and breakdown, organic fertilizer is environmentally friendly. With the ever-more startling warnings from scientists that global warming is fast increasing, every little helps.

Local Sourcing

You can find locally sourced organic fertilizers at some farmer’s markets or dairy farms. It’s plausible that the farmers gather and sell composted manure fertilizer. This is an excellent way to procure manure if you’re so environmentally conscious that you fear the impact of online shopping on the environment. You can also check for local lawn care service providers who will come and do all the work for you!

Time It Well

With your fertilizer selected, it’s time to choose the right time to fertilize your lawn. You can indeed use some organic fertilizers year-round, but they work most efficiently in warm soil.

Consider buying a soil thermometer to check when your soil is at a moderate heat. As seasons can be unpredictable, it’s best to be sure rather than solely base your decision on the time of year.

Get Granules

Liquid fertilizer exists and will spread much faster than fertilizer from a bag. Unfortunately, this isn’t always easy to spread evenly and may require special tools to apply correctly.

Granulated fertilizer in a broadcast spreader is more straightforward and ensures you cover your whole lawn evenly.

Water Well, Yet Infrequently

The more you water your lawn, the more you’re feeding the grass. It’ll grow, but it will use up its nutrients quickly.

So, don’t overwater your lawn, or you’ll have to fertilize more frequently to replenish it—think every six weeks as opposed to every eight.

Different fertilizers will have various watering instructions, so always read the bag.

Use plenty of organic matter to obtain thick green grass

Go Green, Stay Green

If you’re still not convinced that you should go with organic lawn fertilizer over synthetic, you’re probably beyond persuasion by now.

However, if we’ve converted you, the best organic lawn fertilizer is Espoma EOFW30 Organic Fall Fertilizer. You just can’t argue with the before and after pictures that customers posted online.

Espoma is effective, works quickly, and the smell disappears after a little water. This leaves you with a lawn that’s not only lush but won’t send people running away with their mouth and nose covered.

It’s quite pricey, but a little goes a long way, and we think it’s worth the investment.

See also  Power Rake vs Dethatcher vs Scarifier Which Should You Use?